Chemical Guys has been one of the leading names when it comes to car washes. And its three products, Mr. Pink, Honeydew, and Watermelon dominate this market more than anything.
However, what is the difference between Chemical Guys Mr. Pink vs honeydew vs watermelon?
Compared to Honeydew and Watermelon, Mr. Pink has more cleaning power with a cherry-scented aroma. While Mr. Pink is able to produce more foam than honeydew and watermelon, people prefer honeydew. The strongest feature of Chemical guys watermelon is that it has a neutral pH.
While these are just the basics, it’s a good way to start differentiating them. If you want to know more, follow me in the main discussion below!
Overview of the Three Car Wash Products
Even though Mr. Pink, Honeydew, and Watermelon are from Chemical guys, their composition and formulation are quite different. Moreover, they also differ in their use cases.
Here are the basic ingredients and substantial differences between these three products in a mark-down chart-
|Technical Attributes/Features||Mr. Pink||Honeydew||Watermelon|
|Formulation||pH-balanced formula, cherry-scented||pH-balanced formula, honeydew-scented||pH-neutral formula, watermelon-scented|
|Cleaning Power||Strong cleaning power||Medium cleaning power||Mild cleaning power|
|Lubrication||High lubrication||Medium lubrication||Low lubrication|
|Ideal for||All types of vehicles||Ceramic and Metal surfaces||Paint surfaces|
|Dilution Ratio||1-3 oz per 5 gallons or 32 oz water||1-3 oz per 5 gallons or 32 oz water||1-3 oz per 5 gallons or 32 oz water|
|Foam Levels||High foam level||Medium foam level||Low foam level|
A quick reminder that if you want a comparison between Chemical Guys Nonsense & Total interior, you won’t find it here. Because it has been previously discussed so go check that out if you’re curious about those!
With that being said, let’s focus on Mr. Pink, Honeydew, and Watermelon foam washes!
Detailed Comparison of Mr. Pink Vs Honeydew Vs Watermelon
Obviously coming from the same brand, these three products will surely have several similarities. However, there are enough differentiators among them to compare with each other.
The good thing about all of these three car washes is that you can use these to clean rubbing compound that is hard to remove!
Well, that’s enough for the similarities, now let’s compare them without holding back!
Formulation & Ingredients:
As obvious as it may seem, these three products don’t share the same ingredients (Big surprise I know!). Mr. Pink uses a balanced pH level with a sweet cherry scent.
Mr. Pink is ideal for removing tough dirt and grime, and its cherry scent adds a pleasant fragrance to the washing process. That’s what makes Mr. Pink a strong contender in the car wash shampoo market.
Honeydew’s honeydew scent has a more unique and refreshing vibe to it. And its pH-balanced formula makes it safe for frequent use.
On the other hand, Watermelon’s pH-neutral formula is gentle on car surfaces and its watermelon scent is perfect for summertime washes.
Summary: With different formulas, all three car foam soaps offer unique propositions that make them unique.
Mr. Pink has the strongest cleaning power of the three and is suitable for heavily soiled vehicles. Also, the sweet cherry aroma helps with the after-wash experience.
Honeydew is a medium cleaning power formula that is safe for frequent use. However, ceramic surfaces or coating show extra love to Honeydew compared to the other two.
Watermelon has the mildest cleaning power, making it ideal for lightly soiled vehicles. You can definitely expect a good wash from Watermelon as well.
Summary: Mr. Pink has better cleaning power but if you have a ceramic surface, go for Honeydew. For painted surfaces, Watermelon shows its true colors!
As snow foam car soaps, all of these three products are quite excellent in my opinion. However, there are still some subtle differences.
Mr. Pink produces the thickest, most luxurious suds of the three, making it ideal for those who enjoy rich foam during their car wash.
Honeydew is also designed to provide a high level of foam and lubrication, making it ideal for use in a foam cannon or foam gun. The same can be said for Watermelon as well but it falls a bit short on foams compared to the others.
Summary: For the most premium level of foaming, Mr. Pink leads the way with flying colors.
If you are looking for a cleaning snow foam that can be used in most of your vehicles, then Mr. Pink is the best option. You can practically use it on anything and everything.
Metal, Glass, Plastic, and Rubber are the most suitable for Mr. Pink. On the other hand, because of the formulation, Honeydew is more suited to waxes and sealants.
Chemical Guys also recommend using it on ceramic and you can actually do that without much worry. Lastly, compared to Mr. Pink, Honeydew does not leave any residue on your car after cleaning.
For Watermelon, all I can say is that it’s kind of the underdog. It can perform unexpectedly well on paint and gives you a fresh and clean look. However, the versatility is not on par with Mr. Pink and Honeydew.
Summary: Mr. Pink provides a more versatile and wide range of surface cleaning support compared to the other two.
Mainly because of the same parent company, the dilution ratio for all of these foam washes is the same at 2-3 oz in 5 gallons of water. However, even if you take the same amount of soap from each product, the result can vary.
As Mr. Pink is able to give better foams and cleaning, you will be satisfied with 2-3 oz usage. However, the same thing can’t be said for the other two because you might not be happy with their foaming power.
Still, you can expect a good cleaning on your car from all of these products, nonetheless.
Summary: The dilution ratio is the same for all three Chemical Guys products.
The price of these three car wash shampoos are very similar to each other. Mr. Pink, Honeydew, and Watermelon all come in 4 different sizes: 16 oz, 64 oz, 128 oz, and 144 oz.
The most affordable volumes are obviously the 16 oz ones but 64 oz versions are the most popular. So, let’s compare the prices of that particular quantity.
The price of 64 oz Mr. Pink and Honeydew is the same at $20.11 after discounts. However, the price of Watermelon is a tad bit higher at $24.99. While it is not the most versatile one in the bunch, the price is still a bit steep.
If you think that you don’t want to spend too much on car wash shampoos, then there’s a great option for you! And that is water. I know it sounds funny but you can wash your car with just water!
You just have to know the tips and tricks to do it. So, whether you use products from Chemical Guys or just water, the choice is always there!
Summary: Both Mr. Pink and Honeydew are similarly priced while Watermelon has a higher price point.
Summary of the Comparison
Mr. Pink has a strong cleaning power, high foam level, and high lubrication, making it ideal for heavily soiled vehicles.
Honeydew has a medium cleaning power, moderate foam level, and medium lubrication, making it suitable for frequent use.
Watermelon has the mildest cleaning power, low foam level, and low lubrication, making it ideal for lightly soiled vehicles.
All three shampoos are eco-friendly and versatile, but Mr. Pink and Honeydew are more suitable for washing a variety of vehicles
On the other hand, Watermelon is mainly designed for washing small to regular cars. Any heavy vehicle is not ideally suited for Chemical Guys Watermelon car wash shampoo.
Whichever you ultimately choose, keep in mind that just car wash maintenance is not enough for a car’s longevity. So, make sure to regularly check every aspect of your car!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs):
Can I use Chemical Guys Mr. Pink, Honeydew, or Watermelon on a ceramic-coated car?
Yes, all three products are safe to use on ceramic-coated cars. However, it’s always a good idea to check with the manufacturer of your ceramic coating to ensure compatibility with the shampoo.
Do I need to dilute Chemical Guys Mr. Pink, Honeydew, or Watermelon?
Yes, all three products should be diluted with water before use. The recommended dilution ratio for each product varies, so be sure to follow the instructions on the label.
Can I use Chemical Guys Honeydew for foam cannon or foam gun applications?
Yes, you can easily use Chemical Guys Honeydew on foam cannons, foam guns, and simple bucket wash. It has a low dilution ratio which makes it perfect for both personal and professional use.
Now you are fully aware of the differences between chemical guys mr pink vs honeydew vs watermelon!
All that’s left is to choose one and get on with your car wash routine. As all the products are from the same brand, you might not find tons of differences. Just a simple case of preference and that’s about it!
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.